Saturday, July 12, 2014

denying her natural origin

In the article, “All together Now: Intersex infants and IGM”, Ricki Wilkins

awakens the reader to the very real crisis facing intrasex individuals. She makes her

case by using the example of Cheryl, who originally was assigned the sex of a boy but

then later her parents decided on a mutilative surgery to reassign her as a girl.

Claiming that the medical establishment must have the sex of the person in order to

make the person or birth of the person legal or legitimate, Wilkins talks about the trauma

facing the central character and some of her story. Specifically, the author mentions

“IGM's (which) refer to cosmetic genital cutting that is performed solely to make

intersex infants resemble normal males and females.”(Wilkins, pg.126) and the language

that traps the masses into The classifications of male and female.


I had heard about this issue in class and quite honestly was shocked when I heard some of the fine details. I asked myself how I could be in the dark about such a deeply controversial and pertinent issue in todays world. My brother was part of a group in San
Francisco called the “radical billies” which was a gay activist group. At the time it was clear to me to understand how important this type of activism was due to the oppression
of the LGBT community. Wilkins talks about the “discourse” (pg. 127) and the effects of language on body parts and how that can pre-determine an individuals gender assignment which was a shocking revelation. She states that we give power to the labels of gender and race classifications which actually is the mechanism that brings them into existence. I have shared about my experience when someone comes to me and says “you don't look Mexican”. In their minds and ignorance they have created what they think a Mexican should look like.

I must admit at first I thought, “what's the big deal, so a doctor selects their sex. Maybe they are making life easier for them”. But then I realized that this was probably why so many people have been ignorant to the true nature of this problem. I felt I had to dig deeper and understand “the power attached to Charlie's (Cheryl's) body is a different kind of power entirely, one we have little experience in dealing with , let alone have strategies to counter”. Wilkins is not only challenging the status quo but Gay and Lesbian groups to support intersex individuals due to their present vulnerability. The author is bringing this issue to the forefront and through her recollections of encounters with various groups, expressing how much denial society is in regarding this crisis. I agree with her on this point. Wilkins is barely scratching the surface but I concur that we need to bring to light the suffering that intrasex individuals are going through. “They(Intersex Activists) contend that greater safeguards should be adopted to ensure that the rights to liberty and autonomy of people with (a DSD) Intrasex are respected”(Greenberg, abstract).

In conclusion I see intrasex issues as also human rights issues. This points in the direction of holding gender assignment and its mandates as against the sanctity of life. Each person must have the right to decide on her own fate and who she wants to be, whether it be male, female or intrasex.

Bibliography

Greenberg, Julie. June, 2012. Health Care Issues Affecting People with an Intersex Condition or DSD: Sex or Disability? Research Gate.

No comments:

Post a Comment