Friday, July 11, 2014

In Alice Dregers article, "Where's the Rulebook for Sex Verification?" she talks about the ambiguity surrounding sex classification. Speaking to science she mentions the term "Androgen Insensitivity Syndrome"(Dreger, pg. 123) and specifically comments on the case of an athlete named Caster Semenya .  Semenya as a professional track and field athlete, was put on notice by sports governing body, the I.A.A.F, due to doubts of whether she was female or not.  Dreger pushes out the boundaries of what science says constitutes  a man or a woman.  She says, "...a person can have something between a penis and a clitoris, and still legitimately be thought of as a man or a woman"(pg. 123).

This reminds me of when I lived in a student cooperative in college. Many that lived in the house over the course of 4 years were of the LGBT  community.  I remember a young lady named Dina that lived there at one time.  To me she represented both female and male.  She was the most liked people that had ever lived at the house.  There was no pressure to draw a line as to whether she was male or female.  I think we were caught up in the friendship and camaraderie of  being with her.  This element was far more meaningful for us then a gender classification.  I believe that this is what Dreger is leaving us with: The idea that science, no matter how many formulas it comes up with, can not necessarily make the final decision on someones'"sex verification".

I feel that Dreger is onto something here regarding classification and verification.  She points out that there are simply too many variables to work with regarding this matter.  I am beginning to feel the same way as the author when she says, "Sex is so messy in the end , these doctors are not going to be able to run a test that will answer the question".(Dreger, pg. 124)

What I take away from this is something quite intense.  I am coming to an awareness that the definition of men and women is so fluid that it is really beyond what we can comprehend in this present moment.  I will need to have tremendous sensitivity to my students especially in this area.  I am curious to know more so that I can be empowered. This will equip me so that I can help bring others including my students to a full awareness of gender classification issues. And I am seeing that it's not so much what's on the outside of the person as on the inside of the person that counts. "Interior bio/logics (iB/L) refer to a hierarchy in which the most essential features of gender/sex are seen to be the most biologic, and the most biologic are the most interior"(Moreland, pg. 21)

Bibliography

Moreland, Iain. 2014. Transgender Quarterly.  Duke University Press.


No comments:

Post a Comment