Monday, July 14, 2014

race blind

"Loot or Find: Fact or Frame?"(Harris, Carbado, 2005) is a riveting piece, that evoked a sense of deep anger within me, regarding racism in America and commercial media.  The article is commentary on the crisis that occured in the midst of Hurricane Katrina and its aftermath.  The authors talk about the misperceptions in regards to photos and stories that the public heard and saw through mass media during the Katrina event.  They also talk about the prejudice that the authorities, the public and the government had toward blacks and african americans during this catastorphe.  Specifically they assert Americans as victims of "color blindness". Harris et al.'s "the simple fact that the faces of those left to fend for themselves or die were overwhelmingly black raised questions about the explanatory power of color blindness under which race is deemed irrelevant"(pg. 455) pinpoints the basis of this critique.

This was a very startling piece for me to read on a personal level.  Many many times in my life I have been in the midst of conversations where people say "Most mexicans are darker than you, aren't they?" or "you couldn't possibly be mexican, you're too light!".  Again I would be shocked by these comments and found out quickly that the general populous judged people not only by name and ethnic background but by the color of their skin. "As predicted, light skin bestows privileges in education and income for both groups and even higher spousal status for African American women."(Hunter, 2002)  The article also demonstrates that whites and blacks differed greatly in their opinions which also connects to a racial divide.

A majority of Whites saw that the issues with the catastrophe had to do with "bureaucratic inefficiencies"(pg. 456, Harris).  The authors state that most blacks felt it was about "race....(thus) the victims were the black and poor"(pg. 456).  In addition the media accounts were greatly slanted against blacks and african/americans.  I would have to concur with the author in the final assessment.  When they describe how most of the black people were seen as criminals or gang members, I found this to be the tipping point.  At the beginning of the article I felt that there might not be enough evidence and I didn't understand the significance of the captions on the pictures at start of the story.  But by the end I understood that there was an importance in the visual influences of the media as setting the stage for a very biased atmosphere.

I think this is the most important and significant article I have read. It paints a very clear picture of where race issues stand in the United States in the last 10 years.  I am already researching this issue by viewing "When the Levees broke" by Spike Lee.  It's very distressing to see the images in this film.  But one continual theme was that the civilians themselves actually became the first responders.  This part was very inspiring and aligns well with the conclusion of the article which declares that television viewers couldn't assimilate the images of rescuers who also they may have thought were "thugs".  I myself am taking a hard look at these racial stereotypes and how we as Americans can have the wool pulled over our eyes very quickly.


Bibliography

Hunter, Margaret. April 2002. "If You're Light You're Alright": Light Skin Color as Social Capital for Women of Color".  Sage Publications.

No comments:

Post a Comment