Both shocking and sobering, Eva Marie Garroutte's article titled "Real Indians: Identity and the Survival of Native America" targets the great ambiguity to the legalities identities surrounding blood quantum measurements of Native Americans in the U.S. The contradictions regarding this issue do not only prevail in the dominant culture but also within the tribal cultures as well. Garroutte asserts, "The tribes' power to determine citizenship allows them to delimit the distribution of certain important resources, such as reservation land, tribal monies, and political privileges. But this is hardly the end of the story of legal definitions of identity." (Garroutte, pg. 67). The author points to the severity of biological proof as to whether one can prove she is indian. She talks about the fact that laws will sometimes target definitions being Native American and other laws have no definition at all. She also speaks of sub groups such as "mixed bloods" and "full bloods" and the sometimes intense contradiction and ostracization that these groups have against each other.
This reminds me when someone says to me "Why don't you speak with an accent if you're Mexican". It's almost shocking to someone when I say that my last name orients my ethnic heritage toward Mexican American. I feel as Chicano, Mexican American, latino or hispanic as my father may have felt when he grew up in the Mexican Barrios of Los Angeles. Eventhough my parents cooked Beef with Broccholi and spoke mostly English at home, I felt the culture of Mexico deeply engraved in my heart. I related to the authors rendition of Shania Twain's story as an adopted child of a parent, who was a member of the Anishnabe nation of Canada. She may not have had Native American blood but she was steeped in the culture of that tribe. Garoutte seems to continually point to the eternal question: What makes a person Native American? Blood, Culture or Heritage? Or all of the above?
The author really is pointing to the absurdness of how we judge a person's culture by the color of their skin. I remember the story recanted of the difficult decision by a college entrance counselor involving two candidates, one with blue eyes and blonde hair and the other with dark hair, dark skin and brown eyes. The college advisor was committed to how an indian should look by saying "we do want to have Indian people that look like they're Indian to represent us"(Garroutte, pg. 71). The author warns that this stigma is now taking the form of internal scrutiny within the tribe, of people who may not look the part of "Native American".
The idea that someone could be judged within the tribe is utterly ridiculous to me and an example of how human beings simply continue to separate themselves from each other. In my Buddhist practice we have a term called "Many in body, but one in mind"(Writings of Nicheren Daishonin, pg. 283). This means to say that although we come from different backgrounds, we have the same goal which is harmony, sharing of culture and ultimately peace. Maybe my daughter's right when she says that "people need to look beyond color, race and culture and see that we are all just same kind of people, one and the same". I'd have to agree with her. This is my vision of how want to see my students and integrate myself with them and their special gifts.
Bibliography
Daishonin, Nichern. 1999. Writings of Nicheren Daishonin. Soka Gakkai.
Monday, June 30, 2014
so ...Where's the Middle East?
I must say that personally this article titled "From Friendly Foreigner to Enemy Race" by John Tehranian was an eye opener. Tehranian refers to "the term Middle East was used to refer to a region of growing strategic importance in the emerging conflict pitting Britain and the United States against Germany and Russia"(Tehranian, pg. 104) in "1902". This is quite startling in the sense that it is very recent and also that the term is being utilized as geo-political term instead of a representation of the people that actually inhabit the area is quite disturbing according to Tehranian. He goes on to comment on the racialization of the term "middle eastern" and the political necessity of this term primarily by the greater powers such as the U.S. and other nation's interests such as England. The author states the facts and science that most so called "middle easterners" are actually Christian instead of Muslim over the years and could be categorized as white. This is where he targets the actual racial profiling of people from this area in the world. Tehranian states that they could actually labeled as "white de jure" or "nonwhite de facto..."(Tehranian, pg. 108).
So in one instance a person from this area of the world could be criminal and in another she could be a celebrity or role model. A perfect example was that of the famous soccer player Zidane in the 2006 World Cup. The author states that Zidane went from a national soccer hero who was "ordinary native-born (white)"(pg. 108) to an individual who acted out aggresively toward another player and then became, to the media, known as an "Arab"(pg. 108). This is the main thrust of the article which shows how the U.S. has positioned this term in order to further the "War on Terror". It makes one doubt whether or not this War is actually real and if the enemies are really so called "Muslims"? For me this is really about profiling which I know all too well. I was profiled and pulled over for speeding in Vermont. The questions by the officer were clearly "profiling questions". Later I was given a traffic ticket. So I understand not only this issue firsthand, but see how much a stigma can turn someone into a "criminal" or bad person.
Tehranian talks about models that "could be more coercively assimilationist"(pg. 108). This term really describes the thesis of this article. He mentions the "four axes of covering -- association, appearance, affiliation, and activism"(pg. 109). The most striking of these is the affiliation of Iranian Jews to the Jewish world, which can give them the privilege of being more white. This is the most important point. This idea that some Middle Easterners can be white. Somehow depending on how you look and who you hang out with then allows you to become white seems very bizarre but is an excellent point that he makes.
I wonder in what ways I myself as a Mexican American have played the "special privilege" card. I am asking myself some questions regarding this issue especially in terms of racialization. “Selective realization” (pg. 107) is a very serious and controversial issue. Selectively I may have used my voice to sound more “american”. Or maybe I've felt more reassured when someone said “you don't look mexican?”. This is what Tehranian wants us to ponder on, which is the idea that we give special treatment to those who have more whiteness and negative treatment to those who don't have as much whiteness. We even go so far as to call them terrorists if they don't fit our standards of conduct.
So in one instance a person from this area of the world could be criminal and in another she could be a celebrity or role model. A perfect example was that of the famous soccer player Zidane in the 2006 World Cup. The author states that Zidane went from a national soccer hero who was "ordinary native-born (white)"(pg. 108) to an individual who acted out aggresively toward another player and then became, to the media, known as an "Arab"(pg. 108). This is the main thrust of the article which shows how the U.S. has positioned this term in order to further the "War on Terror". It makes one doubt whether or not this War is actually real and if the enemies are really so called "Muslims"? For me this is really about profiling which I know all too well. I was profiled and pulled over for speeding in Vermont. The questions by the officer were clearly "profiling questions". Later I was given a traffic ticket. So I understand not only this issue firsthand, but see how much a stigma can turn someone into a "criminal" or bad person.
Tehranian talks about models that "could be more coercively assimilationist"(pg. 108). This term really describes the thesis of this article. He mentions the "four axes of covering -- association, appearance, affiliation, and activism"(pg. 109). The most striking of these is the affiliation of Iranian Jews to the Jewish world, which can give them the privilege of being more white. This is the most important point. This idea that some Middle Easterners can be white. Somehow depending on how you look and who you hang out with then allows you to become white seems very bizarre but is an excellent point that he makes.
I wonder in what ways I myself as a Mexican American have played the "special privilege" card. I am asking myself some questions regarding this issue especially in terms of racialization. “Selective realization” (pg. 107) is a very serious and controversial issue. Selectively I may have used my voice to sound more “american”. Or maybe I've felt more reassured when someone said “you don't look mexican?”. This is what Tehranian wants us to ponder on, which is the idea that we give special treatment to those who have more whiteness and negative treatment to those who don't have as much whiteness. We even go so far as to call them terrorists if they don't fit our standards of conduct.
Of
all the articles that I have read , this one in particular inspires
me to critically analyze the terms and labels that society and the
political establishment espouses. In some ways it makes me feel
angry that we , as citizens of the U.S., have bought into these
stigmas. These labels echo into much larger and complex
socio-political agendas which can do much damage to populations both
large and small. As for myself as a teacher, I feel a deeper
sensitivity to oppresive labels having to do with students of
specific backgrounds.
Tuesday, June 17, 2014
lets hear it for the cool rich kids...
Retell few benchmark quotes. Cite with APA author. DTE. pg..
Recall- this reminds me of personal...is also my own experience of the articleReact- this author seems to be espousing and whether you agree.my view of authors opinion.
Rethink- makes me think did. Ask ? Bout perspective.
In the article "In Defense of Rich Kids", Upski Wimsatt makes a plea for "Rich" kids to be "cool"(Wimsatt, pg. 508) and make contributions to grass roots organizations in America and around the world. He opens up with his own story of having the fortune to end up with a considerable amount of funds without having to do any work to get it. Wimsatt talks about the fact that only 2% of Americans give to charity. He talks about the need for wealthy young people to give to grassroots groups instead of just "Big churches, colleges or services"(Wimsatt, pg. 510). Finally Wimsatt emplores his readers to help him find those "cool rich people" that could help redouble the cause of grass roots social change.
I myself did have the privledge of growing up in a somewhat upper class community in silicon valley, California. I can relate to Wimsatt's desire to wake up the other rich kids. I am glad that at one point in my life I decided to go off on my own and separate myself from the community I grew up in. This time period allowed me to grow into the person I am today by studying subjects like equal rights, chicano studies, Buddhism, and social justice issues. This is what I feel the author has achieved in being able to look from the outside in. He is able to see broader possiblities for people with wealth. Wimsatt has also helped start movements amongst his community to help at the grass roots level like "Active Element, Self Education, and Third Wave Foundations and the Comfort Zone". This type of individual and collective initiative is something that I wholeheartedly believe in.
Wimsatt is assserting that people should not get caught up in judging people, especially the younger generation, but instead see how they can bring this wealthier population into the area of grass roots work for a better society that is based on equity. I completely agree with his call to action. He even speaks to the value of the poorer populations having an influence on where not only society goes, but where the wealthier people contribute their money. The author is also helping readers recognize an important principle: "The vast majority of money goes to big churches , big colleges, big hospitals, big arts, and social service service organziaitons which either directly cater to privileged people, or which treat the symptoms of social ills without ever addressing the root causes..."(Wimsatt, pg. 510). This is an important distinction that I think many people from all stratas of life need to be aware of.
""A corollary of the empowerment assumption is that dialogue holds enormous potential power to transform downtrodden individuals into proactive groups who will rewrite their history"(Pilisuk, 1996). Thus these wealthier communities Pilisuk et al.'s (1996), being able to dialogue and realize that they can take true ownership of the problems in the world and express a sense of caring, is something significant that I can observe from this article. It's important to begin the discourse amongst related communities in the microcosm so that it can be brought into the greater communitites. As a teacher I feel it's important to treasure each student as a global expert that can bring fresh and new perspectives to the problems that the world faces.
Bilibliography:
Pilisuk, Marc, McAllister, JoAnn, Rothman.1996. Journal of Social Issues, Vol.52.No.1., pp.15-37
Coming Together for Action: The Challenge of Contemporary Grassroots Community Organizing.
I myself did have the privledge of growing up in a somewhat upper class community in silicon valley, California. I can relate to Wimsatt's desire to wake up the other rich kids. I am glad that at one point in my life I decided to go off on my own and separate myself from the community I grew up in. This time period allowed me to grow into the person I am today by studying subjects like equal rights, chicano studies, Buddhism, and social justice issues. This is what I feel the author has achieved in being able to look from the outside in. He is able to see broader possiblities for people with wealth. Wimsatt has also helped start movements amongst his community to help at the grass roots level like "Active Element, Self Education, and Third Wave Foundations and the Comfort Zone". This type of individual and collective initiative is something that I wholeheartedly believe in.
Wimsatt is assserting that people should not get caught up in judging people, especially the younger generation, but instead see how they can bring this wealthier population into the area of grass roots work for a better society that is based on equity. I completely agree with his call to action. He even speaks to the value of the poorer populations having an influence on where not only society goes, but where the wealthier people contribute their money. The author is also helping readers recognize an important principle: "The vast majority of money goes to big churches , big colleges, big hospitals, big arts, and social service service organziaitons which either directly cater to privileged people, or which treat the symptoms of social ills without ever addressing the root causes..."(Wimsatt, pg. 510). This is an important distinction that I think many people from all stratas of life need to be aware of.
Bilibliography:
Pilisuk, Marc, McAllister, JoAnn, Rothman.1996. Journal of Social Issues, Vol.52.No.1., pp.15-37
Coming Together for Action: The Challenge of Contemporary Grassroots Community Organizing.
Monday, June 16, 2014
They Thought we had Overcome
In the article, "Between Barack and a Hard Place", Tim Wise explains that a Black or African/American citizen's rise to success does not necessarily mean equality for all people. Regarding Obama's election, Wise et al.'s (2013)"...it most definitely does not suggest that racism has been truncated as an ongoing social problem for persons of color generally". Wise actually starts his article with the pro side of the Obama win. He talks about whites finally talking with their pocketbooks in support of a black politician in large numbers. Wise also refers to the unprecedented combination of cross racial support of Obama, especially amongst younger activists and voters. Finally he returns to the central point, which is that no matter how many African Americans hit it big in the U.S., that does not necessarily mean an end to racial tension and racism in America.
My own experience of the article is that Wise is attempting to paint a very specific picture for the reader. He argues fiercely that we have not necessarily progressed, as a nation regarding racial issues, easing of racial tension and equality for opportunity, as we think we have. He gives an example when Rudy Giulani proclaims that "we've moved beyond ...the whole idea of race and racial separation and unfairness"(Wise, 267). Wise questions as to what would happen if Obama lost? Would that mean that "we had not overcome the race issue as a people". Thus he points to the foolishness of some of our assumptions. Wise is pointing to the fact that we aren't dissecting the issue enough. We have to be far reaching in our research and analysis of racism in our country in at the present time.
I believe that Wise is helping us to see the broader issue of race in our country and not relying on one instance as the deciding factor. As a minority in this country, I still feel it's important to recognize every single achievement made by us. It's not fair to say that although some minorities, latinos, asian americans and african americans have created individual and broader victories, that there is little effect on the ethnic population as a whole. I disagree with this premise.
What I am taking away from this article is not to get caught up on one news story of triumph, but to recognize other areas of racial equality that are occuring. How do large events effect the smaller incremental steps? This is very important. Some of the causes toward racial equality that are being made now, simply can not be fully seen and digested by the masses in the present moment. But I believe that many behind the scenes actions are creating great amounts of leverage for minorities toward the near and distant future. And on the other hand it's always important to stay alert and on our toes to insure that equality progresses and to continue to "I am dreaming of an America that does not yet exist..."(Harding, WT 2014, April).
Bilibliography:
Harding Vincent, April 4th, 2014, Becoming a New America. SGI USA, World Tribune Press.
My own experience of the article is that Wise is attempting to paint a very specific picture for the reader. He argues fiercely that we have not necessarily progressed, as a nation regarding racial issues, easing of racial tension and equality for opportunity, as we think we have. He gives an example when Rudy Giulani proclaims that "we've moved beyond ...the whole idea of race and racial separation and unfairness"(Wise, 267). Wise questions as to what would happen if Obama lost? Would that mean that "we had not overcome the race issue as a people". Thus he points to the foolishness of some of our assumptions. Wise is pointing to the fact that we aren't dissecting the issue enough. We have to be far reaching in our research and analysis of racism in our country in at the present time.
I believe that Wise is helping us to see the broader issue of race in our country and not relying on one instance as the deciding factor. As a minority in this country, I still feel it's important to recognize every single achievement made by us. It's not fair to say that although some minorities, latinos, asian americans and african americans have created individual and broader victories, that there is little effect on the ethnic population as a whole. I disagree with this premise.
What I am taking away from this article is not to get caught up on one news story of triumph, but to recognize other areas of racial equality that are occuring. How do large events effect the smaller incremental steps? This is very important. Some of the causes toward racial equality that are being made now, simply can not be fully seen and digested by the masses in the present moment. But I believe that many behind the scenes actions are creating great amounts of leverage for minorities toward the near and distant future. And on the other hand it's always important to stay alert and on our toes to insure that equality progresses and to continue to "I am dreaming of an America that does not yet exist..."(Harding, WT 2014, April).
Bilibliography:
Harding Vincent, April 4th, 2014, Becoming a New America. SGI USA, World Tribune Press.
Friday, June 13, 2014
"cooked rats"
"Wow"I thought to myself, "someone could actually cook a rat to prove their manhood!" This was expressed in the article, "PROVING MANHOOD" ("Compulsive Masculinity in The United States") by Timothy Benecke, as a tactic used by conservative radio commentator G. Gordon Liddy to prove his masculinity as a younger person. The article opens with commentary on a Life magazine story by Norman Mailer on Muhammed Ali and how he simply needed to "take it like a man"(pg. 255). There was also one quote from the article that struck me, "American men take pride in handling alcohol like a man--getting sick or drunk, becoming incompetent, too easily can threaten one's manhood".This is an acute and stigmatic reference that has been created by both men and the society at large. It's part of the complex web of a proving ground for men that Benecke refers to. And beyond this aspect, is the idea that men are confering upon themselves or other men the title of "manhood". Compulsive masculinity is an avenue of this conferal or proof which includes confronting any harm to one's "manhood". For example, not being able to handle physical pain or danger could be a threat to masculinity according to Benecke. Other alleyways of this avenue may be "not acting like a sissy" or being able to "handle the stress like a man".
Something quite fascinating is how Benecke comments on how a man is threatened by a woman when he is in the middle of "masculinity-threatening" crisis (pg.257). Also how a man has to prove himself through sex and be amply "potent"(257). Explained in the article, there is also a superiority that certain men must feel to women. I know several men of this nature and never could explain why they acted in such a way. I feel that Benecke has targeted many of the reasons why so many men are defensive of their conferals of manhood, which to me is an important assertion toward this gender problem. I also notice in my own life that many men feel the need to swear which the references in the article. This has been unusual to me, especially with men who have children. I have asked myself ,"don't they see that they are setting a bad example for their kids?". But now that I see that their very "male" existence can be threatened, I can understand why.
Benecke also alludes to the idea of men being able to overcome this crisis by learning from women and gay men. Specifically he mentions at the end, "the liberatory potential that gay men offer straight men". This is a very powerful assertion for these men in crisis and explains the resistance to our feminine sides and the plague of homophobia that still exists around the world today. I feel that Benecke speaks to this topic that is rarely addressed in our society. Although, I do feel that it is a much more complex issue than what he describes at the surface. For example, I know someone who demonstrates all the characteristics of "compulsive masculinity" but tends to love cuddly animals and babies. So there appears to be a more complex matrix of hyper-masculation assertion then what is addressed in the article.
Due to this compulsive and unconscious behaviour, men suffer greatly at a spiritual, emotional and physical level. Courtenay et al.'s(2013) describes this: "Men in the United States are more likely than women to adopt beliefs and behaviours that increase their risks, and are less likely to engage in behaviours that are linked with health and longevity". As a teacher I am excited to know that I can make a difference with my students by helping them to become aware of equity, equality and tolerance of diversity, race, gender and sexual orientation.
Bilibliography:
Will H Courtenay(2013). Constructions of masculinity and their influence on men's well-being: a theory of gender and health. Social Science & Medicine, Volume 50, Issue 10, Pages 1385-1401
Something quite fascinating is how Benecke comments on how a man is threatened by a woman when he is in the middle of "masculinity-threatening" crisis (pg.257). Also how a man has to prove himself through sex and be amply "potent"(257). Explained in the article, there is also a superiority that certain men must feel to women. I know several men of this nature and never could explain why they acted in such a way. I feel that Benecke has targeted many of the reasons why so many men are defensive of their conferals of manhood, which to me is an important assertion toward this gender problem. I also notice in my own life that many men feel the need to swear which the references in the article. This has been unusual to me, especially with men who have children. I have asked myself ,"don't they see that they are setting a bad example for their kids?". But now that I see that their very "male" existence can be threatened, I can understand why.
Benecke also alludes to the idea of men being able to overcome this crisis by learning from women and gay men. Specifically he mentions at the end, "the liberatory potential that gay men offer straight men". This is a very powerful assertion for these men in crisis and explains the resistance to our feminine sides and the plague of homophobia that still exists around the world today. I feel that Benecke speaks to this topic that is rarely addressed in our society. Although, I do feel that it is a much more complex issue than what he describes at the surface. For example, I know someone who demonstrates all the characteristics of "compulsive masculinity" but tends to love cuddly animals and babies. So there appears to be a more complex matrix of hyper-masculation assertion then what is addressed in the article.
Due to this compulsive and unconscious behaviour, men suffer greatly at a spiritual, emotional and physical level. Courtenay et al.'s(2013) describes this: "Men in the United States are more likely than women to adopt beliefs and behaviours that increase their risks, and are less likely to engage in behaviours that are linked with health and longevity". As a teacher I am excited to know that I can make a difference with my students by helping them to become aware of equity, equality and tolerance of diversity, race, gender and sexual orientation.
Bilibliography:
Will H Courtenay(2013). Constructions of masculinity and their influence on men's well-being: a theory of gender and health. Social Science & Medicine, Volume 50, Issue 10, Pages 1385-1401
Thursday, June 12, 2014
Immigration and Identity
In Carola Saurez-Orozco's article "Formulating Identity in a Globalized World", she paints a vivid picture of the complexities within the areas of immigration, identity and social mirroring of minority citizens. She discusses the threats of globalization to immigrants as well as first and second generation born citizens in the last century. Suarez-Orozco also comments on the plight of first and second generation individuals. She speaks to the confusion that faces the second generation due to the schism between the dominant culture and culture of origin. The most confusing element is the "Identity" (Suarez-Orozco, pg.222) of the individual. With so many choices , they are caught between the native born aspects of their host country and the dominant culture of the current country they live in.
Orozco then goes on to talk about "Identity Formation" as both "Ascribed and Achieved Identities"(Orozco, pg. 223). Identity formation is intricate as it tests a sense of identity not just as a tug of war between two cultures but also in the example of an individual questioning which part of her homeland (i.e. China) she is identifying with. She also comments on "ethnic activites vs. dominant culture activities" and social mirroring. What is the result when a child or youth receives positive encouragement as oppossed to negative reinforcment regarding her ethnic roots. Finally Orozco speaks of the various identity platforms such as "Coethnic, Transcultural as well as ethnic flight and gendered differences"(Orozco, pg. 231).
This article reminded me of the book "Hunger of Memory"(The Education of Richard Rodriguez, Random House,1983) by Richard Rodriguez. In this seminal book, Rodriguez speaks of his assimilation to the dominant culture as an ethnic triumph. Throughout the book he shares about growing up as a Mexcian-American young man in the United States and his struggle to become educated and assimilated. I related to the book and the Orozco article because of my own crisis of assimilation, growing up as a chicano in an anglo saxon community in California. The only time in my schooling where I felt someone reached out to me was when I befreinded a young african american man in high school. This was an example of the neglect that the dominant culture can have for native cultures, "other ethnic cultures and immigrants.
I am currently viewing an immigration series on PBS. In part 5 (PBS, 2013) there is specific commentary regarding the juxtaposition of immigrant identity and the challenge of becoming educated. Many middle schoolers were told in East LA in the 60's (PBS, 2013) were told that they would never amount to anything. Orozco comments on some of the "inequalities and psychological disparagement" of immigrants and minorities in education. Social and Culture mirroring was also very weak within the community I grew up in. Due to the fact that it was dominantly European American, very few people were awakened to the idea of multiculturalism. This made it very difficult to feel proud of who I am as a Mexican American or have positive reflections mirrored back to me.
I feel that Orozco is moving toward a solution for immigrants and second generation citizens and their cultural identity. She talks about the modern day understanding of "bi-culturalism" (Orozco, pg. 232) and its advantages. I feel more in line when Orozco refers to Arnett et al.'s"a 'complex hybrid'"(pg. 232) as a more honest definition of today's ethnic populations. She says that "a number of studies in the past two decades have demonstrated a link between racial and ethnic identity pathways and academic outcomes".(Orozco, pg 231). I agree that a solid identity can lead to a more solid education. I feel that embracing "a complex hybrid" or transcultural identity is a global means of educating, in both citizenry and scholarly realms.
I come back to the question of "what does it mean for a young person or student as an immigrant or person of foreign/ethnic background to become happy and fulfilled in the arena of citizenry and school?". Goulah et al.'s (2009) states "Happiness, Makiguchi argued, is forged through the creation of value in the interchange of beauty, gain, and good". Beauty is an internal satisfaction within the individual while gain carries the ethnic minority to expand beyond assimilation and cultural identity and into the global community and an individual's livelihood. Good is the means for minorities and immigrants to create a positive affect in the nation they live in (TsunesaburoMakiguchi, 1981–1988). I feel that it's important to start with a premise of local identity with both culture and geology. In other words, living in Vermont it's easy to connect with nature and natural surroundings. In addition it's important to expose students and children to different cultures, languages, and ethnic cuisine. In my experience as a substitute teacher, students seem to be appreciate these aspects of global cultures. And especially for immigrant or first and second generation ethnic students, this becomes a powerful means of social mirroring, integration and placing themselves within the larger macrosystem of society.
Bibliliography:
Rodriguez, Richard, Hunger of Memory-The Education of Richard Rodriguez-Random House. 1982.
Bosch, Adriana(Producer) PBS: LATINO AMERICANS, Pride and Prejudice. 2013
Makiguchi Tsunesaburo Zenshu [The Complete Works of Tsunesaburo. Makiguchi, Tokyo: Daisan Bunmeisha, 1981–96. [10 vols. ... 1]. 1983 . : Bunkaido Shoten, (1903)
Orozco then goes on to talk about "Identity Formation" as both "Ascribed and Achieved Identities"(Orozco, pg. 223). Identity formation is intricate as it tests a sense of identity not just as a tug of war between two cultures but also in the example of an individual questioning which part of her homeland (i.e. China) she is identifying with. She also comments on "ethnic activites vs. dominant culture activities" and social mirroring. What is the result when a child or youth receives positive encouragement as oppossed to negative reinforcment regarding her ethnic roots. Finally Orozco speaks of the various identity platforms such as "Coethnic, Transcultural as well as ethnic flight and gendered differences"(Orozco, pg. 231).
This article reminded me of the book "Hunger of Memory"(The Education of Richard Rodriguez, Random House,1983) by Richard Rodriguez. In this seminal book, Rodriguez speaks of his assimilation to the dominant culture as an ethnic triumph. Throughout the book he shares about growing up as a Mexcian-American young man in the United States and his struggle to become educated and assimilated. I related to the book and the Orozco article because of my own crisis of assimilation, growing up as a chicano in an anglo saxon community in California. The only time in my schooling where I felt someone reached out to me was when I befreinded a young african american man in high school. This was an example of the neglect that the dominant culture can have for native cultures, "other ethnic cultures and immigrants.
I am currently viewing an immigration series on PBS. In part 5 (PBS, 2013) there is specific commentary regarding the juxtaposition of immigrant identity and the challenge of becoming educated. Many middle schoolers were told in East LA in the 60's (PBS, 2013) were told that they would never amount to anything. Orozco comments on some of the "inequalities and psychological disparagement" of immigrants and minorities in education. Social and Culture mirroring was also very weak within the community I grew up in. Due to the fact that it was dominantly European American, very few people were awakened to the idea of multiculturalism. This made it very difficult to feel proud of who I am as a Mexican American or have positive reflections mirrored back to me.
I feel that Orozco is moving toward a solution for immigrants and second generation citizens and their cultural identity. She talks about the modern day understanding of "bi-culturalism" (Orozco, pg. 232) and its advantages. I feel more in line when Orozco refers to Arnett et al.'s"a 'complex hybrid'"(pg. 232) as a more honest definition of today's ethnic populations. She says that "a number of studies in the past two decades have demonstrated a link between racial and ethnic identity pathways and academic outcomes".(Orozco, pg 231). I agree that a solid identity can lead to a more solid education. I feel that embracing "a complex hybrid" or transcultural identity is a global means of educating, in both citizenry and scholarly realms.
I come back to the question of "what does it mean for a young person or student as an immigrant or person of foreign/ethnic background to become happy and fulfilled in the arena of citizenry and school?". Goulah et al.'s (2009) states "Happiness, Makiguchi argued, is forged through the creation of value in the interchange of beauty, gain, and good". Beauty is an internal satisfaction within the individual while gain carries the ethnic minority to expand beyond assimilation and cultural identity and into the global community and an individual's livelihood. Good is the means for minorities and immigrants to create a positive affect in the nation they live in (TsunesaburoMakiguchi, 1981–1988). I feel that it's important to start with a premise of local identity with both culture and geology. In other words, living in Vermont it's easy to connect with nature and natural surroundings. In addition it's important to expose students and children to different cultures, languages, and ethnic cuisine. In my experience as a substitute teacher, students seem to be appreciate these aspects of global cultures. And especially for immigrant or first and second generation ethnic students, this becomes a powerful means of social mirroring, integration and placing themselves within the larger macrosystem of society.
Bibliliography:
Rodriguez, Richard, Hunger of Memory-The Education of Richard Rodriguez-Random House. 1982.
Bosch, Adriana(Producer) PBS: LATINO AMERICANS, Pride and Prejudice. 2013
Makiguchi Tsunesaburo Zenshu [The Complete Works of Tsunesaburo. Makiguchi, Tokyo: Daisan Bunmeisha, 1981–96. [10 vols. ... 1]. 1983 . : Bunkaido Shoten, (1903)
Monday, June 2, 2014
Chicano Flavored Ice Cream
In her article, "Latinos and the U.S. Race Structure", Clara Rodriguez talks about the complicated structures of race and ethnic classifications with the Latino communities of the United States. She opens with her own experience of growing up as Latina in America saying, "I came to see that this Euro centric bias, which favors European characteristics above all others, was part of our history and cultures(Rodriguez, pg.236)". She utilizes the idea of "Euro centrism" to explain the complications of identifying people according to their skin color, and physical looks. She also accords these difficulties with "class or political position".
Rodriguez often cites "lighter" and "darker" as descriptors which only exacerbate the puzzle of class, color and status within and outside of the Latino populous. She argues that Latinos can select from a smorgasbord of racial classifications. Race identification and self identification for Latinos can go down many different avenues. The article goes on to comment about the hopes of future dialogues on race and origin amongst Latino communities as well as deciphering various understandings of classification terms.
Rodriguez wraps up the article with the term "racialization process"(Rodriguez, p. 239), which is basically the indoctrination of immigrants, foreign citizens and Latinos into the structure of labelization and classification of race and ethnicity in the U.S. The basic crux of racialization is the idea of status or authority. She refers to it as almost an addiction in American culture to see who's better than the other person. For example she states that the word Hispanic has a couple different meanings with one being: "subtly 'colored' by negative and racial asociations"(Rodriguez, p.239).
The article examines something like "Chicano flavored ice cream". Depending on the mood I am in, my current status or life position I can choose from a variety of race, ethnic or cultural label flavors. If I fear I won't be able to get a job I may mark the box that says "other" on a job application. If I feel that they will hire me if I am a minority then I may check off "Hispanic". Rodriguez claims that the census bureau supports the notion of consistency which means where there is no social context, people do have a tendency to consistently check the same box of Hispanic. She does not delve into this topic too deeply but owns the fact that it exists. This makes me think about the instance when people hear me speak english after finding out that I am Mexican American. Some are surprised that I do not have an accent. This has been rather shocking to me. I would ask myself "Should I speak with an accent?". Thus she speaks to this question of doubt. I wonder about doubting who I am. There have been many times where I also ask; "Am I white, am I mexican, what am I?".
I will agree to a certain extent with Rodriguez, but feel as though the hard data is missing. What are the stats and numbers of people who have actually experienced this. She says throughout the article that she hopes people can come togehter to discuss solutions. Although Rodriguez says she has hopes for discussions she doesn't demonstrate what that process would look like.
The article has inspired me to think about my own experience of being latino in a white world and how important it is to claim my roots. Many people say I don't look Mexican, but then I challenge them and say "well then I guess you haven't been to Mexico". Which is true! If one goes to Mexico, one will find many different shades of Latino or Mexicano. I ask myself about the fear my parents went through based on their reality at the time. I feel times have improved but it's important to stay alert of the potential racial pressures in society and how to overcome them.
Rodriguez often cites "lighter" and "darker" as descriptors which only exacerbate the puzzle of class, color and status within and outside of the Latino populous. She argues that Latinos can select from a smorgasbord of racial classifications. Race identification and self identification for Latinos can go down many different avenues. The article goes on to comment about the hopes of future dialogues on race and origin amongst Latino communities as well as deciphering various understandings of classification terms.
Rodriguez wraps up the article with the term "racialization process"(Rodriguez, p. 239), which is basically the indoctrination of immigrants, foreign citizens and Latinos into the structure of labelization and classification of race and ethnicity in the U.S. The basic crux of racialization is the idea of status or authority. She refers to it as almost an addiction in American culture to see who's better than the other person. For example she states that the word Hispanic has a couple different meanings with one being: "subtly 'colored' by negative and racial asociations"(Rodriguez, p.239).
The article examines something like "Chicano flavored ice cream". Depending on the mood I am in, my current status or life position I can choose from a variety of race, ethnic or cultural label flavors. If I fear I won't be able to get a job I may mark the box that says "other" on a job application. If I feel that they will hire me if I am a minority then I may check off "Hispanic". Rodriguez claims that the census bureau supports the notion of consistency which means where there is no social context, people do have a tendency to consistently check the same box of Hispanic. She does not delve into this topic too deeply but owns the fact that it exists. This makes me think about the instance when people hear me speak english after finding out that I am Mexican American. Some are surprised that I do not have an accent. This has been rather shocking to me. I would ask myself "Should I speak with an accent?". Thus she speaks to this question of doubt. I wonder about doubting who I am. There have been many times where I also ask; "Am I white, am I mexican, what am I?".
I will agree to a certain extent with Rodriguez, but feel as though the hard data is missing. What are the stats and numbers of people who have actually experienced this. She says throughout the article that she hopes people can come togehter to discuss solutions. Although Rodriguez says she has hopes for discussions she doesn't demonstrate what that process would look like.
The article has inspired me to think about my own experience of being latino in a white world and how important it is to claim my roots. Many people say I don't look Mexican, but then I challenge them and say "well then I guess you haven't been to Mexico". Which is true! If one goes to Mexico, one will find many different shades of Latino or Mexicano. I ask myself about the fear my parents went through based on their reality at the time. I feel times have improved but it's important to stay alert of the potential racial pressures in society and how to overcome them.
HUMAN RIGHTS , HUMANE EDUCATION
In the article HUMAN RIGHTS, DIVERSITY, and CITIZENSHIP EDUCATION(Banks, 2009), Banks declares "Structural inclusion, cultural empowerment, equality, and recognition are essential conditions for the internalization of human rights, values, attitudes, and behaviors". This piece is written in the spirit of the 60th anniversary of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights(UDHR) This opening statement by Banks seems to cover several broad areas. In the article Banks expounds on the idea that ethnic diversity in nations around the globe has grown exponentially. How does a nation empower such diverse populations? To me this is the central question.
He contends that the chief obstacles to this platform of empowerment are "Assimilationist and liberal idealogies" that pressure individuals to give up their racial, ethnic and cultural identities. Democracy and Modernity sometimes don't realistically blend well according to Banks.
He then explores the possibility of training students through "Citizenship education" and how to recognize and embrace localized and global identifications of citizenry. He alludes to the solution of Cosmopolitanism" which coupled with "Citizenship education" can help students to identify a "deep understanding of the need to take action as citizens of a global community to help actualize social justice and human rights for people around the globe"(Banks).
My own experience of the article is that Banks is attempting to bring the (UDHR) into the classroom at both a localized and universal level. I was struck by the four basic processes of social interactions of assimilationists that Banks comments on, which are "contact, competition, accommodation and assimilation". These may seem like beneficial processes but according to the "ethnic revitalization movements of the 60's and 70s" (Banks 2009) the processes were the cause of grave problems for ethnic empowerment. I experienced the most contradictory elements of this article being "Modernization" vs. "Tradition".
How does one who has migrated to a different country or has a very different ethnic background, compared to the local community, identify themselves in a holistic way to their country and county both culturally and globally? From the article I experienced "Citizenship education" as "humane citizenship" (Goulah 2012), meaning that the student becomes aware of their humaness and how that interconnects with the world and other humans. In Soka education, Ikeda et al's(2010)"ningen kyoikuin" expands the idea of cosmopolitan citizenship as "the idea, principle, process, and goal of becoming fully human in the truest sense(in and outside school)".
Thus Banks tries to bring it all together so that students begin to have the ability to reflect on and thoughtfully critique their immediate local environment with that of the greater macrocosm along with the goal of "true" global citizenry and "actualizing social justice"(Banks). I wanted to see how Banks would connect the UDHR with a concrete process of actually going about teaching "citizenry". In Soka education the process is peace, environmental, developmental and then ultimately human rights education(Goulah). Even though I am excited about Banks article, I feel its Critical to discuss some of the steps in achieving a cosmopolitan awareness as a migrant or ethnic minority. For example, I think its important to start with peace and environment education which slowly adapt the student to issues that are localized and global without the immediate pressure to take action which could be premature.
This piece was refreshing as it comes at a time when I am evaluating ,critically, my role as an educator. I am one of the ethnic minorities that Banks speaks of. My family migrated from Mexico in the 1920's. Thus the article brings to mind my own schism with growing up as a U.S. citizen and how that effects my identity as a Chicano or Mexican American if you will. My parents never wanted to teach us Spanish for fear of us losing touch with our U.S. citizenry. They even stopped cooking Mexican dishes and rather replaced them with entrees like "beef and broccoli". This was the pressure of assimilation at the time coupled with the ethnic revitalization movements. These movements are an even stronger echo now. It allows me again in my life as an educator to come to a place of greater compassion for my minority and ethnic students and myself.
Goulah, Jason (2012)Daisaku Ikeda's Curriculum of soka Education: Creating Value Through Dialogue, Global Citizenship, and "Human Education" in the Mentor-Disciple Relationship: OISE #42
Ikeda, Daisaku (2010) Soka Education: Middleway Press
He contends that the chief obstacles to this platform of empowerment are "Assimilationist and liberal idealogies" that pressure individuals to give up their racial, ethnic and cultural identities. Democracy and Modernity sometimes don't realistically blend well according to Banks.
He then explores the possibility of training students through "Citizenship education" and how to recognize and embrace localized and global identifications of citizenry. He alludes to the solution of Cosmopolitanism" which coupled with "Citizenship education" can help students to identify a "deep understanding of the need to take action as citizens of a global community to help actualize social justice and human rights for people around the globe"(Banks).
My own experience of the article is that Banks is attempting to bring the (UDHR) into the classroom at both a localized and universal level. I was struck by the four basic processes of social interactions of assimilationists that Banks comments on, which are "contact, competition, accommodation and assimilation". These may seem like beneficial processes but according to the "ethnic revitalization movements of the 60's and 70s" (Banks 2009) the processes were the cause of grave problems for ethnic empowerment. I experienced the most contradictory elements of this article being "Modernization" vs. "Tradition".
How does one who has migrated to a different country or has a very different ethnic background, compared to the local community, identify themselves in a holistic way to their country and county both culturally and globally? From the article I experienced "Citizenship education" as "humane citizenship" (Goulah 2012), meaning that the student becomes aware of their humaness and how that interconnects with the world and other humans. In Soka education, Ikeda et al's(2010)"ningen kyoikuin" expands the idea of cosmopolitan citizenship as "the idea, principle, process, and goal of becoming fully human in the truest sense(in and outside school)".
Thus Banks tries to bring it all together so that students begin to have the ability to reflect on and thoughtfully critique their immediate local environment with that of the greater macrocosm along with the goal of "true" global citizenry and "actualizing social justice"(Banks). I wanted to see how Banks would connect the UDHR with a concrete process of actually going about teaching "citizenry". In Soka education the process is peace, environmental, developmental and then ultimately human rights education(Goulah). Even though I am excited about Banks article, I feel its Critical to discuss some of the steps in achieving a cosmopolitan awareness as a migrant or ethnic minority. For example, I think its important to start with peace and environment education which slowly adapt the student to issues that are localized and global without the immediate pressure to take action which could be premature.
This piece was refreshing as it comes at a time when I am evaluating ,critically, my role as an educator. I am one of the ethnic minorities that Banks speaks of. My family migrated from Mexico in the 1920's. Thus the article brings to mind my own schism with growing up as a U.S. citizen and how that effects my identity as a Chicano or Mexican American if you will. My parents never wanted to teach us Spanish for fear of us losing touch with our U.S. citizenry. They even stopped cooking Mexican dishes and rather replaced them with entrees like "beef and broccoli". This was the pressure of assimilation at the time coupled with the ethnic revitalization movements. These movements are an even stronger echo now. It allows me again in my life as an educator to come to a place of greater compassion for my minority and ethnic students and myself.
Goulah, Jason (2012)Daisaku Ikeda's Curriculum of soka Education: Creating Value Through Dialogue, Global Citizenship, and "Human Education" in the Mentor-Disciple Relationship: OISE #42
Ikeda, Daisaku (2010) Soka Education: Middleway Press
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)