Friday, June 13, 2014

"cooked rats"

"Wow"I thought to myself, "someone could actually cook a rat to prove their manhood!"  This was expressed in the article, "PROVING MANHOOD" ("Compulsive Masculinity in The United States") by Timothy  Benecke, as a tactic used by conservative radio commentator G. Gordon Liddy to prove his masculinity as a younger person.  The article opens with commentary on a Life magazine story by Norman Mailer on Muhammed Ali and how he simply needed to "take it like a man"(pg. 255).  There was also one quote from the article that struck me, "American men take pride in handling alcohol like a man--getting sick or drunk, becoming incompetent, too easily can threaten one's manhood".This is an acute and stigmatic reference that has been created by both men and the society at large.  It's part of the complex web of a proving ground for men  that Benecke refers to.  And beyond this aspect, is the idea that  men are confering upon themselves or other men the title of "manhood".  Compulsive masculinity is an avenue of this conferal or proof which includes confronting any harm to one's "manhood".  For example, not being able to handle physical pain or danger could be a threat to masculinity according to Benecke.  Other alleyways of this avenue may be "not acting like a sissy" or being able to "handle the stress like a man".

Something quite fascinating is how Benecke comments on how a man is threatened by a woman when he is in the middle of "masculinity-threatening" crisis (pg.257).  Also how a man has to prove himself through sex and be amply "potent"(257).  Explained in the article, there is also a superiority that certain men must feel to women.  I know several men of this nature and never could explain why they acted in such a way.  I feel that Benecke has targeted many of the reasons why so many men are defensive of their conferals of manhood, which to me is an important assertion toward this gender problem. I also notice in my own life that many men feel the need to swear which the references in the article.  This has been unusual to me, especially with men who have children.  I have asked myself ,"don't they see that they are setting a bad example for their kids?".  But now that I see that their very "male" existence can be threatened, I can understand why.

Benecke also alludes to the idea of men being able to overcome this crisis by learning from women and gay men.  Specifically he mentions at the end, "the liberatory potential that gay men offer straight men".  This is a very powerful assertion for these men in crisis and explains the resistance to our feminine sides and the plague of homophobia that still exists around the world today.  I feel that Benecke speaks to this topic that is rarely addressed in our society.  Although, I do feel that it is a much more complex issue than what he describes at the surface.  For example, I know someone who demonstrates all the characteristics of "compulsive masculinity" but tends to love cuddly animals and babies.  So there appears to be a more complex matrix of hyper-masculation assertion then what is addressed in the article.

Due to this compulsive and unconscious behaviour, men suffer greatly at a spiritual, emotional and physical level. Courtenay et al.'s(2013) describes this: "Men in the United States are more likely than women to adopt beliefs and behaviours that increase their risks, and are less likely to engage in behaviours that are linked with health and longevity".  As a teacher I am excited to know that I can make a difference with my students by helping them to become aware of equity, equality and tolerance of diversity, race, gender and sexual orientation.

Bilibliography:

Will H Courtenay(2013). Constructions of masculinity and their influence on men's well-being: a theory of gender and health. Social Science & Medicine, Volume 50, Issue 10, Pages 1385-1401




2 comments:

  1. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Richard,
    This male internal impulse to avoid peer sanctions by behaving in certain ways reminds me of chickens in the farmyard. Roosters strut and preen and battle in a never-ending cycle of dominance and mating. The hens go to the winner. The loser skulks around until he has a chance to try again. I accept that our views of masculinity are mostly a social construct, and the fact that other cultures value different traits as masculine and feminine bears that out somewhat. But however a culture defines masculinity, it is still used as a sorting tool by the females. Perhaps women no longer need a man who can bring home the bacon literally, but it is still considered an attractive trait figuratively. Even as women move up the pay scale (and still only make about three-fourths of the wages of a man), there are other traits of ‘masculinity’ that identify a good mate. How much of this male posturing do you think is based on biological patterns? It’s not like roosters have socially constructed the ideal male rooster traits!

    ReplyDelete