In her article, "Latinos and the U.S. Race Structure", Clara Rodriguez talks about the complicated structures of race and ethnic classifications with the Latino communities of the United States. She opens with her own experience of growing up as Latina in America saying, "I came to see that this Euro centric bias, which favors European characteristics above all others, was part of our history and cultures(Rodriguez, pg.236)". She utilizes the idea of "Euro centrism" to explain the complications of identifying people according to their skin color, and physical looks. She also accords these difficulties with "class or political position".
Rodriguez often cites "lighter" and "darker" as descriptors which only exacerbate the puzzle of class, color and status within and outside of the Latino populous. She argues that Latinos can select from a smorgasbord of racial classifications. Race identification and self identification for Latinos can go down many different avenues. The article goes on to comment about the hopes of future dialogues on race and origin amongst Latino communities as well as deciphering various understandings of classification terms.
Rodriguez wraps up the article with the term "racialization process"(Rodriguez, p. 239), which is basically the indoctrination of immigrants, foreign citizens and Latinos into the structure of labelization and classification of race and ethnicity in the U.S. The basic crux of racialization is the idea of status or authority. She refers to it as almost an addiction in American culture to see who's better than the other person. For example she states that the word Hispanic has a couple different meanings with one being: "subtly 'colored' by negative and racial asociations"(Rodriguez, p.239).
The article examines something like "Chicano flavored ice cream". Depending on the mood I am in, my current status or life position I can choose from a variety of race, ethnic or cultural label flavors. If I fear I won't be able to get a job I may mark the box that says "other" on a job application. If I feel that they will hire me if I am a minority then I may check off "Hispanic". Rodriguez claims that the census bureau supports the notion of consistency which means where there is no social context, people do have a tendency to consistently check the same box of Hispanic. She does not delve into this topic too deeply but owns the fact that it exists. This makes me think about the instance when people hear me speak english after finding out that I am Mexican American. Some are surprised that I do not have an accent. This has been rather shocking to me. I would ask myself "Should I speak with an accent?". Thus she speaks to this question of doubt. I wonder about doubting who I am. There have been many times where I also ask; "Am I white, am I mexican, what am I?".
I will agree to a certain extent with Rodriguez, but feel as though the hard data is missing. What are the stats and numbers of people who have actually experienced this. She says throughout the article that she hopes people can come togehter to discuss solutions. Although Rodriguez says she has hopes for discussions she doesn't demonstrate what that process would look like.
The article has inspired me to think about my own experience of being latino in a white world and how important it is to claim my roots. Many people say I don't look Mexican, but then I challenge them and say "well then I guess you haven't been to Mexico". Which is true! If one goes to Mexico, one will find many different shades of Latino or Mexicano. I ask myself about the fear my parents went through based on their reality at the time. I feel times have improved but it's important to stay alert of the potential racial pressures in society and how to overcome them.
Hi Richard,
ReplyDeleteIt is interesting that you mention the author's negative association with the term "Hispanic". My husband and I lived for a year in Santa Fe, New Mexico, and I seem to remember that many people claimed the Hispanic label which was connected to their ancestry to Spain, and did not want to be referred to as Latino, since they were not from Latin America. In college I dated someone from Venezuela (here on a student Visa), and he simply considered himself Venezuelan. I think he later became a citizen of the US, so perhaps he now considers himself a Latino, or perhaps not.
Carla