In Carola Saurez-Orozco's article "Formulating Identity in a Globalized World", she paints a vivid picture of the complexities within the areas of immigration, identity and social mirroring of minority citizens. She discusses the threats of globalization to immigrants as well as first and second generation born citizens in the last century. Suarez-Orozco also comments on the plight of first and second generation individuals. She speaks to the confusion that faces the second generation due to the schism between the dominant culture and culture of origin. The most confusing element is the "Identity" (Suarez-Orozco, pg.222) of the individual. With so many choices , they are caught between the native born aspects of their host country and the dominant culture of the current country they live in.
Orozco then goes on to talk about "Identity Formation" as both "Ascribed and Achieved Identities"(Orozco, pg. 223). Identity formation is intricate as it tests a sense of identity not just as a tug of war between two cultures but also in the example of an individual questioning which part of her homeland (i.e. China) she is identifying with. She also comments on "ethnic activites vs. dominant culture activities" and social mirroring. What is the result when a child or youth receives positive encouragement as oppossed to negative reinforcment regarding her ethnic roots. Finally Orozco speaks of the various identity platforms such as "Coethnic, Transcultural as well as ethnic flight and gendered differences"(Orozco, pg. 231).
This article reminded me of the book "Hunger of Memory"(The Education of Richard Rodriguez, Random House,1983) by Richard Rodriguez. In this seminal book, Rodriguez speaks of his assimilation to the dominant culture as an ethnic triumph. Throughout the book he shares about growing up as a Mexcian-American young man in the United States and his struggle to become educated and assimilated. I related to the book and the Orozco article because of my own crisis of assimilation, growing up as a chicano in an anglo saxon community in California. The only time in my schooling where I felt someone reached out to me was when I befreinded a young african american man in high school. This was an example of the neglect that the dominant culture can have for native cultures, "other ethnic cultures and immigrants.
I am currently viewing an immigration series on PBS. In part 5 (PBS, 2013) there is specific commentary regarding the juxtaposition of immigrant identity and the challenge of becoming educated. Many middle schoolers were told in East LA in the 60's (PBS, 2013) were told that they would never amount to anything. Orozco comments on some of the "inequalities and psychological disparagement" of immigrants and minorities in education. Social and Culture mirroring was also very weak within the community I grew up in. Due to the fact that it was dominantly European American, very few people were awakened to the idea of multiculturalism. This made it very difficult to feel proud of who I am as a Mexican American or have positive reflections mirrored back to me.
I feel that Orozco is moving toward a solution for immigrants and second generation citizens and their cultural identity. She talks about the modern day understanding of "bi-culturalism" (Orozco, pg. 232) and its advantages. I feel more in line when Orozco refers to Arnett et al.'s"a 'complex hybrid'"(pg. 232) as a more honest definition of today's ethnic populations. She says that "a number of studies in the past two decades have demonstrated a link between racial and ethnic identity pathways and academic outcomes".(Orozco, pg 231). I agree that a solid identity can lead to a more solid education. I feel that embracing "a complex hybrid" or transcultural identity is a global means of educating, in both citizenry and scholarly realms.
I come back to the question of "what does it mean for a young person or student as an immigrant or person of foreign/ethnic background to become happy and fulfilled in the arena of citizenry and school?". Goulah et al.'s (2009) states "Happiness, Makiguchi argued, is forged through the creation of value in the interchange of beauty, gain, and good". Beauty is an internal satisfaction within the individual while gain carries the ethnic minority to expand beyond assimilation and cultural identity and into the global community and an individual's livelihood. Good is the means for minorities and immigrants to create a positive affect in the nation they live in (TsunesaburoMakiguchi, 1981–1988). I feel that it's important to start with a premise of local identity with both culture and geology. In other words, living in Vermont it's easy to connect with nature and natural surroundings. In addition it's important to expose students and children to different cultures, languages, and ethnic cuisine. In my experience as a substitute teacher, students seem to be appreciate these aspects of global cultures. And especially for immigrant or first and second generation ethnic students, this becomes a powerful means of social mirroring, integration and placing themselves within the larger macrosystem of society.
Bibliliography:
Rodriguez, Richard, Hunger of Memory-The Education of Richard Rodriguez-Random House. 1982.
Bosch, Adriana(Producer) PBS: LATINO AMERICANS, Pride and Prejudice. 2013
Makiguchi Tsunesaburo Zenshu [The Complete Works of Tsunesaburo. Makiguchi, Tokyo: Daisan Bunmeisha, 1981–96. [10 vols. ... 1]. 1983 . : Bunkaido Shoten, (1903)
No comments:
Post a Comment