Monday, June 30, 2014

so ...Where's the Middle East?

I must say that personally this article titled "From Friendly Foreigner to Enemy Race" by John Tehranian was an eye opener.  Tehranian refers to "the term Middle East was used to refer to a region of growing strategic importance in the emerging conflict pitting Britain and the United States against Germany and Russia"(Tehranian, pg. 104) in "1902".  This is quite startling in the sense that it is very recent and also that the term is being utilized as geo-political term instead of a representation of the people that actually inhabit the area is quite disturbing according to Tehranian.  He goes on to comment on the racialization of the term "middle eastern" and the political necessity of this term primarily by the greater powers such as the U.S. and other nation's interests such as England.  The author states the facts and science that most so called "middle easterners" are actually Christian instead of Muslim over the years and could be categorized as white.  This is where he targets the actual racial profiling of people from this area in the world.  Tehranian states that they could actually labeled as "white de jure" or "nonwhite de facto..."(Tehranian, pg. 108).

So in one instance a person from this area of the world could be criminal and in another she could be a celebrity or role model.  A perfect example was that of the famous soccer player Zidane in the 2006 World Cup.  The author states that Zidane went from a national soccer hero who was "ordinary native-born (white)"(pg. 108) to an individual who acted out aggresively toward another player and then became, to the media, known as an "Arab"(pg. 108).   This is the main thrust of the article which shows how the U.S. has positioned this term in order to further the "War on Terror".  It makes one doubt whether or not this War is actually real and  if the enemies are really so called "Muslims"?  For me this is really about profiling which I know all too well.  I was profiled and pulled over for speeding in Vermont.  The questions by the officer were clearly "profiling questions".  Later I was given a traffic ticket.  So I understand not only this issue firsthand, but see how much a stigma can turn someone into a "criminal" or bad person.


Tehranian talks about models that "could be more coercively assimilationist"(pg. 108).  This term really describes the thesis of this article.  He mentions the "four axes of covering -- association, appearance, affiliation, and activism"(pg. 109).  The most striking of these is the affiliation of Iranian Jews to the Jewish world,  which can give them the privilege of being more white.  This is the most important point.  This idea that some Middle Easterners can be white.  Somehow depending on how you look and who you hang out with then allows you to become white seems very bizarre but is an excellent point that he makes.


I wonder in what ways I myself as a Mexican American have played the "special privilege" card.  I am asking myself some questions regarding this issue especially in terms of racialization. “Selective realization” (pg. 107) is a very serious and controversial issue. Selectively I may have used my voice to sound more “american”. Or maybe I've felt more reassured when someone said “you don't look mexican?”. This is what Tehranian wants us to ponder on, which is the idea that we give special treatment to those who have more whiteness and negative treatment to those who don't have as much whiteness. We even go so far as to call them terrorists if they don't fit our standards of conduct.

Of all the articles that I have read , this one in particular inspires me to critically analyze the terms and labels that society and the political establishment espouses. In some ways it makes me feel angry that we , as citizens of the U.S., have bought into these stigmas. These labels echo into much larger and complex socio-political agendas which can do much damage to populations both large and small. As for myself as a teacher, I feel a deeper sensitivity to oppresive labels having to do with students of specific backgrounds.

No comments:

Post a Comment