Both shocking and sobering, Eva Marie Garroutte's article titled "Real Indians: Identity and the Survival of Native America" targets the great ambiguity to the legalities identities surrounding blood quantum measurements of Native Americans in the U.S. The contradictions regarding this issue do not only prevail in the dominant culture but also within the tribal cultures as well. Garroutte asserts, "The tribes' power to determine citizenship allows them to delimit the distribution of certain important resources, such as reservation land, tribal monies, and political privileges. But this is hardly the end of the story of legal definitions of identity." (Garroutte, pg. 67). The author points to the severity of biological proof as to whether one can prove she is indian. She talks about the fact that laws will sometimes target definitions being Native American and other laws have no definition at all. She also speaks of sub groups such as "mixed bloods" and "full bloods" and the sometimes intense contradiction and ostracization that these groups have against each other.
This reminds me when someone says to me "Why don't you speak with an accent if you're Mexican". It's almost shocking to someone when I say that my last name orients my ethnic heritage toward Mexican American. I feel as Chicano, Mexican American, latino or hispanic as my father may have felt when he grew up in the Mexican Barrios of Los Angeles. Eventhough my parents cooked Beef with Broccholi and spoke mostly English at home, I felt the culture of Mexico deeply engraved in my heart. I related to the authors rendition of Shania Twain's story as an adopted child of a parent, who was a member of the Anishnabe nation of Canada. She may not have had Native American blood but she was steeped in the culture of that tribe. Garoutte seems to continually point to the eternal question: What makes a person Native American? Blood, Culture or Heritage? Or all of the above?
The author really is pointing to the absurdness of how we judge a person's culture by the color of their skin. I remember the story recanted of the difficult decision by a college entrance counselor involving two candidates, one with blue eyes and blonde hair and the other with dark hair, dark skin and brown eyes. The college advisor was committed to how an indian should look by saying "we do want to have Indian people that look like they're Indian to represent us"(Garroutte, pg. 71). The author warns that this stigma is now taking the form of internal scrutiny within the tribe, of people who may not look the part of "Native American".
The idea that someone could be judged within the tribe is utterly ridiculous to me and an example of how human beings simply continue to separate themselves from each other. In my Buddhist practice we have a term called "Many in body, but one in mind"(Writings of Nicheren Daishonin, pg. 283). This means to say that although we come from different backgrounds, we have the same goal which is harmony, sharing of culture and ultimately peace. Maybe my daughter's right when she says that "people need to look beyond color, race and culture and see that we are all just same kind of people, one and the same". I'd have to agree with her. This is my vision of how want to see my students and integrate myself with them and their special gifts.
Bibliography
Daishonin, Nichern. 1999. Writings of Nicheren Daishonin. Soka Gakkai.
No comments:
Post a Comment